Sign On Opportunity and Comment Template for the Proposed Residence Rule

On September 10 the Census Bureau issued a proposed residence rule and rules for demographic questions for the 2030 census.

This rule poses a grave threat to the full count of children and their families and would make even worse the already significant undercount of young children. It also would prohibit the collection of data on race and ethnicity in the Decennial Census. In addition to the policy problems that creates, it would, by the Census Bureau’s admission, end a critical benchmark for all the Bureau’s surveys and other critical public and private data collections, making them gradually less and less accurate.

The Coalition on Human Needs, a steering committee member of Count All Kids, has developed a comment on the impact of this proposal on children which it invites organizations to sign. Members of the Count All Kids Committee provided invaluable input on this comment. You can read the comment here, and sign on to the comment here.

We hope you will sign the group comment (and other comments being circulated that address other aspects of the rule that are of significance for your organization), circulate this sign on opportunity to other organizations that advocate for or serve children and families, and consider drafting your own sign on comment that explains the impact that this rule will have in your state or community.

If your organization is drafting comments and you would like to see a longer set of comments being prepared for CHN submission for additional content, please email Debbie Stein at dstein@chn.org.

Comments can be submitted here or here before 11:59 pm eastern time on November 2 (the original deadline was extended) or mailed before that date to 4600 Silver Hill Road, Designation: ADDEMO/FRN, Washington, DC 20746.

Some of the ways that you can customize this comment for your organization include:

  • Discussing how a time extension for this rule would improve your ability to analyze its impact in your state or community.
  • Describing the work your organization does, and how the proposed rule would affect your work.
  • Describing the community you work with, and how the proposed rule might affect their willingness to participate in the 2030 Census or affect their being counted (for example by not having a tax record at the IRS). If you conducted outreach efforts in 2020, it may be helpful to discuss your experiences and what you learned from them. If your state has a high share of young children, you may want to note that and explain how an undercount of young children would harm everyone in the state.
  • A description of the 2020 undercount in your state and in your counties, which you can find here, as part of a discussion of why this proposal would make the undercount worse.
  • Discussing the impact on children in immigrant families in your state, including data on the share of children and young children in your state with at least one immigrant parent (which may include parents who are naturalized citizens or permanent residents); this MPI tool can provide that number. If your immigrant community is showing reluctance to participate in public benefits, school, or other systems that might draw the attention of ICE, you can add examples of that and explain how that shows that a citizenship or immigration status question might make them less likely to respond to the Census.
  • Adding information on how your state uses decennial data or other federal survey data such as the American Community Survey to allocate federal funds received by your state (such as for child care), or how your state uses this data to allocate state funds (such as education funds), and how much money is so allocated. Your state demographer or state data center  or state finance agency may be able to provide you with some of this information.
  • Sharing information on how Medicaid funding provides a critical set of services for children and families in your state, and how a reduction in funding due to an undercount would harm children.
  • Discussing how this rule would harm particular geographic areas of your state—for example, poor communities where few people file federal taxes or have W2 or 1099 forms.
  • Stating whether your state provides 1095 forms for Medicaid and CHIP recipients to the IRS and in what time frame—would the Census Bureau be able to use them to confirm residences for people on SSI or other people who have no earned income but do have health care coverage. Note that we do not know if or when the IRS would then provide those forms to the Census Bureau, and when they need to receive them to include those people in the Census if they have no other tax record. (We know from the Census administrative report that it received Medicaid records too late to be included in the 2020 census but we do not know if that included the 1095 forms.)
  • Giving examples of how policy makers in your state have relied on data from the Decennial Census, Vintage Population Estimates, the American Community Survey, the National Survey on Children’s Health, or other federal data surveys, to improve the lives of children in your state.
  • Giving examples of how you and others in your state use this data to improve the lives of children in your state.

The more you can customize your comments, the more useful that will be. But even if you can’t include most of this, it is still worth submitting separate comments.

Comments are important for several reasons. They must be reviewed and responded to by the Bureau when it releases its final rule. The Bureau may change the final rule in response to your concerns. Comments provide a basis for litigation if the Bureau has failed to consider them, or if the issues raised in comments provide a legal basis for overturning the rule in whole or in part. Comments help demonstrate public support for or against the rule, and elevate interest in Congress and in future administrations in changing problematic features of the rule. Comments can persuade members of Congress and other policy makers to approach the administration privately to urge changes. There has already been notable press attention to this rule, and we anticipate more.

CHN will also be circulating comments specifically about the implications of the tax documentation requirement in this rule for low-income families in a few days, and we will post those here as well for you to join. In addition, there is a growing body of resources for developing your own comments available at HandsOffOurCens.US and at Roadmap to the 2030 Census. You can find recordings from past webinars and registration for future webinars here.  We are happy to share the following resources developed by Voices for Virginia’s children which may be useful models (remember to update the submission date to November 2):

Other items of interest include the Census Bureau’s Regulatory Impact Analysis and a Census Comment Countdown Challenge on LinkedIn and Instagram.  You can email questions@handsoffourcens.us with questions about the proposed rule generally, and dstein@chn.org with questions specifically about the implications for children and families.

Found this article helpful? Share it!

More resources like this

Media Coverage of the Impact of the Proposed Residence Rule on Children

We are sharing some pieces that draw public attention to the terrible consequences for children

Comment Period Extended for Residence Rule

On Friday, October 2, the Census Bureau announced that the comment period for theproposed residence

CHN Comments to the Independent Census Scientific Committee and Committee Recommendations

CHN submitted the following comments to the Independent Census Scientific Committee for its fall 2026